Good vs. Evil
An interview with Norman Mailer
There was a time when Norman Mailer used to talk about the Big Book. It prowled the interviews he gave in the ’50s like a white whale, blasting into view and then diving back down into darkness, where it would lurk until the next publication date.
With each decade, and each new book, from The American Dream to Executioner’s Song, it seemed like Mailer might still drag his promised catch to shore.
Though Joan Didion concludes Mailer finally got his big fish—four times, in fact—the lion remains unconvinced. And approaching his 84th birthday, America’s most pugilistic novelist has done something unusual. He’s beginning to say he may not get it.
“I may have made announcements 50 years ago of the kind of book I was going to write,” says Mailer at his home in Provincetown, a fishing village turned weekend retreat at Cape Cod’s tip. “But I’m not going to stick to those predictions.”
What’s unusual is Mailer is making this pronouncement on the eve of his latest book, his 36th, The Castle in the Forest, an audacious novel that tells the story of Hitler’s first 17 years through the eyes of D.T., an assistant of the Devil himself.
Mailer has worked on the book long enough to lose track of when he started exactly. In the interim, his knees have gone out, meaning he now walks with the aid of two canes. During the course of the interview he does not stand.
“There was one early review that was essentially favorable, but irritated the hell out of me,” says Mailer, revealing a flash of his former feistiness, his smile turning wicked. “Let’s say it irritated the shit out of me. Because the reviewer said in some long-winded way, of course, Mailer is just rewriting Freud.
“Why? Because I paid attention to toilet training. Well, as a father of eight children I do know a little bit about toilet training.”
The evidence of this assertion surrounds him. The end tables in the room are stacked four deep with photographs of Mailer's offspring. Several paintings of Mailer line the walls—a large one hangs in the front office depicting himself and his sixth wife, Norris Church Mailer, and a friend in Havana. Large windows open onto the bay and the ocean beyond.
In this comfortable setting, it seems odd that Mailer should be so compelled to delve back down into “the reek of the urine, the shit, and the blood of Luther,” so manifest throughout The Castle in the Forest.
But as early reviews have noted, that’s exactly what he has done. This is a fascinating, exceptionally dirty book that also happens to want to turn the clock of America's cosmology back a few 60 years.
Mailer believes the world is run by a threesome—God, man and the Devil—and that Hitler was the Devil's response to Jesus Christ.
The most vivid scene of The Castle in the Forest involves Hitler’s bawdy, raucous, incestuous conception—with the Devil inserting himself into young Adolf’s soul at the moment of his parents' climax. “Look, I thought back on my life and there were some fucks that were just evil,” he says.
As provocative as this sounds, Mailer says he is not being facetious. “We can understand Joseph Stalin in a way,” he says. “He was one of the very toughest men in Russia. Hitler was not that tough. It was as if odd gifts were given to him at extraordinary moments.”
Mailer says such gifts can only have come from the Devil, who he believes works all the time. “Maybe every year there are a 1,000 people invested by the Devil or a million people? Then they either come to fruition or they don’t.”
Hitler, in Mailer's view, was a highpoint of the Devil's handiwork. Something he says his mother acknowledged early on. “My mother was very affected by Hitler,” he says.
“When I was 9 years old, she knew already, long before the statesmen did, that Hitler was a disaster and a monster. That he was probably going to kill half the Jews, if not all of them.”
Mailer has long thought he would write this book. But first he had to get to The Gospel According to the Son,” which told Christ’s story in his own words. The idea for that book came to him in a Paris hotel room. Mailer couldn’t sleep, so he picked up the Bible.
“I thought, 'This is such a funny book.’ It’s got sentences that are worthy of Shakespeare, but most of it is dreadful. Then I thought, 'There are 100 writers in the world who could do a better job.' And I’m one of them.”
Mailer wrote the book and got slaughtered for it, and today, even he admits, “I felt I didn’t quite bring it off.”
“I felt like I was making a reach for the material,” he says judiciously.
With Hitler, though, Mailer says he did not feel this barrier. For starters, spending time with a very bad man was not a problem, as he learned from writing about Lee Harvey Oswald in Oswald’s Tale.
“You know your characters don’t need to be there to make you happy with how wonderful they are and how warm-hearted they are and how human they are—you can write about a monster, and so far as you enjoy writing, enjoy the work.”
Mailer used to put in marathon writing sessions, but has become accustomed to five, six hours at a stretch, sometimes without lunch if he became absorbed. Although the book contains an extensive bibliography, Mailer was pleased to be plowing the dark, too.
“There is very little known about Hitler’s childhood,” he says. “He concealed much of it, to the best of his best ability.” So Mailer ad-libbed, speculating about his parents’ incestuous relationship to a degree that outstrips history. He also invents a libidinous beekeeper and, most interestingly, invests a good deal of the book’s energy into bringing to life Hitler’s father, Alois, who emerges as a grabbing, greedy, sexually ravenous customs official.
Mailer manages to make him an almost sympathetic character. “I felt for him,” Mailer says. “I mean: He is a man. And say what you will about him, he’s got balls.”
Long ago, Mailer might have felt some apprehension with this project, knowing the kind of reviews it would spark. Now the picadors of reviewers won't bring him down. “One of the advantages of getting old is you really don’t give a fuck anymore. What are they going to do, come and kill me? Fine, make a martyr of me! Make me immortal!”
As a Jewish writer, he says he has also long been ready to approach Hitler with a cool head. “I remember the first time I visited Germany in the ’50s I was very much on edge.”
But not now, and with current events going the way they are, Mailer says there might be a lesson here for Americans.
“My feeling now is all countries can potentially become monstrous nations--and I think the last few years here, it’s not as if we became a monstrous nation. But for the first time in Americans’ lives, the possibility is so.”
In other words, the Devil is not entirely responsible for Hitler’s rise to power. Conditions made it possible, too, and so vigilance of governments and what they do is key.
“Given the hideous conditions in Germany after the First World War, not only the shame and humiliation of losing that war in an extraordinary thoroughgoing way,” Mailer continues to rattle off the social context of Hitler’s rise.
“Given all that, all the conditions were there for a monster to take over the country.” And yet, to say that those factors alone created Hitler, to Mailer, is not enough for him.
“I’m not here to guarantee it. But I’m saying we won’t understand this unless we go back to the notion--that maybe God and the Devil do exist!”