alibi online

Free Will AstrologyAlibi's Personals
 
 V.17 No.18 | May 1 - 7, 2008 
 
Jeff Drew
 

Feature

Good Medicine

An interview with the man who met the medicine men

An appropriate adjective to describe Charles Langley--or at least Charles Langley's former self--would be "distinguished," or, at the very least, "respectable." A wife, three kids, two cars, two cats, a large loft and a job as the night news editor of the Evening Standard, an eminent London newspaper: all the makings of a modern happily ever after.

But today, sitting across from Langley at the newly reopened Blue Dragon Coffeehouse, my eyes flitting between the diamond in his left ear and the turquoise on his wrist, listening to his tales of skinwalkers, parallel universes and the spirits of deceased snakes, I imagine people would probably choose other words to describe this displaced Englishman. But one word Langley won't accept is "mystic."

Langley calls himself a "man of science," which is why it's so baffling to him that for the past three-plus years he's found himself in the near-exclusive company of Navajo medicine men, observing phenomena he would have previously referred to as "New Age." But when the kids moved out and the divorce was final, Langley found himself suddenly able to escape a lifestyle he had come to find breathless.

 
Nolan Rudi
 

It started with a drive across the U.S. ("Don't ask me why; I just thought it was a good idea.") and ended with Langley abandoning his London life to work as an assistant to a medicine man he refers to as Blue Horse. Blue Horse is a primary character in a book Langley wrote about his experiences, due to hit shelves in May. Meeting the Medicine Men: An Englishman's Travels Among the Navajo is the first of a series of books Langley plans to write on this culture that’s little understood to those outside of it. Langley's thrown by what he's seen and experienced during his time on the Navajo reservation, and he's looking for an outlet to share what he now knows, or at least is coming to find out.

Now splitting his time between working with the medicine men and going to school to earn a degree in anthropology at UNM, Langley settles into his seat. He sips his coffee slowly between excited monologues, recounting the adventures that led him to this cerebral rebirth. The story winds through a storm in Louisiana that forced him out of the rain and into Madame Cecelia's Bed and Breakfast ("except there was never any breakfast").

One day at Madame Cecelia's, while searching for nonexistent rations, Langley opened a cupboard. Instead of food, a confusion of plastic plates and bolts of cloth spilled onto the floor. Unable to stuff them back inside the cupboard, Langley apologized to Madame Cecelia for the mess.

"Oh," she said. "That's for the Indians."

What Indians?

Charles Langley (right) talks to a boy named Eddie at the Gathering of Nations.
Nolan Rudi
Charles Langley (right) talks to a boy named Eddie at the Gathering of Nations.

Some guy in the area, don't ask me why, had gotten it into his head to bring some Navajo code talkers out for their Mardi Gras two years earlier. And they stood on this float, going through the streets. And local people had apparently gotten all these gifts, and they had left before they had the chance to give them to them.

How bizarre.

So if you look at Route 66, it goes right past Window Rock, [Ariz.], which is a place I've always wanted to go. And [Madame Cecelia] said, “Oh, the Navajos, they live at Window Rock.” And I said, “I'm going to Window Rock.” So I said I’d bring it to them.

So I go to Window Rock, and I had no idea about the [Navajo] reservation. It's the size of Ireland. I thought I'd just stop the first person on the street, you know, and ask, do you know these people? (laughs)

It turned out that the evening I arrived was the one day of the year all of the code talkers were at Window Rock because they have a big parade for them, and six out of the seven were actually there. And this guy comes up to me and is like, “I've never seen no white man like you before.” This guy was a medicine man.

Did you know he was a medicine man at the time?

I soon found out. And to cut it all very short, I met more through him. And he said, well, we think you're one of us--you may not know this, but you're one of us, and we think you ought to come learn more about it. That's essentially how it began. That's a truncated version.

“It was like the floor had been peeled back, and suddenly I as looking down into a completely different universe.” —Charles Langley
Nolan Rudi
“It was like the floor had been peeled back, and suddenly I as looking down into a completely different universe.” —Charles Langley

Is that when you started studying with them?

Soon after. I met the guy who I based Blue Horse on at a medicine ritual. He said I could come along, be his assistant.

You see, the medicine men don't teach anything. Indians don't do that. You observe and you have the opportunity to learn if you wish to do so, but they're not going to teach you anything. They'll explain things if I ask ...

But there are no lessons.

Not lessons on How to Be a Medicine Man 101 or anything like that; you just tag along. They do a lot of divination in the fire; they look into the fire and they see things. And I see pretty well for an Indian, I tell you what, but I don't really understand what I'm seeing. Because I'm not Indian, I'm not actually understanding a lot of it. It's pretty extraordinary stuff. I've seen people cured ...

“Cured” is a strange word to use; I mean, even modern medicine doesn't use the word "cure." But I've seen people recover, and I have no real idea how they do it.

Recover from what kinds of things?

This is where you start running into a serious problem from a scientific point of view. There are a couple of examples in the book that are just ... atypical. I mean, they're just stunning.

There was this woman who had been having trouble for some time. I don't know if you know this, but the Navajos believe in witchcraft; they attribute a lot of things that happen to them--bad luck, car crashes, getting sick--to being bewitched by somebody's curse. Now this particular family was having a bit of trouble in that way. So they called a medicine man. Now I've been working with this guy for, what, 18 months at least? He looked [in the divination fire] and he said, “When your husband died 10 years ago, you buried him in a bracelet.”

“I thought, the next time it knocks, I'm going to throw this door and I'm going to smack it in the face.”

It's called a protection bracelet. And she said, “Yeah, my husband didn't really believe in our traditional ways, but he wore this protection bracelet for me.” And he said, “Well, shortly after he was buried, the witches dug him up, and they took the bracelet, and they're using it to curse you.” And he said, “They're trying to finish you off this time.” And he's a very powerful medicine man. He said, “They're now using the bead to curse you. I'm going to come tomorrow to your house, and I'm going to find that curse, and I'm going to lift that curse off you forever.” He said, “I'll bring the bead to you, and you'll recognize it.”

“Razzle Dazzle” at the Gathering of Nations
Nolan Rudi
“Razzle Dazzle” at the Gathering of Nations

What was your reaction to that?

I'd never heard him say something like that. And I thought, if he doesn't pull this off, what are we going to do, you know? He's sunk as a medicine man if he doesn't pull this one off. So I spent the night pretty restless. I mean, I'd never seen him not pull anything off before, but this one really worried me because he was so precise. In fact, I nearly said to him: You know, if you don't think you can do this, tell me now, and I'll try to find a way out of it.

So we went to the house, and he looked into the fire, and he said, “The witch man is cursing you, and he knows I'm here; he's looking into his fire and he can see me. He's coming after you real quick.”

We went outside the house, and he's looking, and he says, “It's there.” I was going to dig it up, because he has a bad back. And as I'm going to, this truck's coming toward us, and he said, “It's the witch man.” They knew who he was. And this truck rolls ahead about 80 yards away. And Blue Horse is going, “Ah, he can't hurt us, I've got my whistle in my pocket.” And I was just about panicking.

So I stuck the spade in and started digging. I took the spade out, and there was this curse. Now, Navajo curses are actually physical objects. We unwrapped it, and there was the bracelet, and there was was the bead. And we took it in, and we showed her the bead. And she said, “Yeah, that's the bead I buried my husband in.” They went out again, and I was left with the widow. So I took the opportunity to say to her, “Are you sure that was the bead?” She said, “There's no question about it.”

And what happened afterward?

Well, we haven't heard from them since, so I guess things are going well.

What was happening beforehand with the family?

Things were just going really badly for them. I mean, it's not like there's one thing, more like a series of things--people get ill, money drains out, people lose their jobs, you know. Eventually a Navajo family will say, this isn't right; this isn't just bad luck, this is something else. And they'll call a medicine man. Whereas sometimes we go there and the medicine man says, this is just a run of bad luck. We'll just do a blessing for you and everything will be fine.

What's the other example?

There's this other one that was amazing. We went to this place; this guy's wife is a nurse for a hospital in Farmington, right? It's actually a very good amalgam of an ancient/traditional/modern sort of family: The kids play computer games, the mother's a nurse, the dad's a carpenter and is a bit more traditional. And he's got this problem with his neck, and it got so bad that he couldn't work because he couldn't use his arm. He'd been to the hospital two or three times; they weren't able to cure him, and the X-rays couldn't find it, and finally he said, I want to see a medicine man. So we went there.

And Blue Horse says, “Did you ever kill a snake?” I could see the snake in the fire--there was a kind of track of life in the fire. He said, “No, I've never killed a snake.” He said, “Are you sure?” “Oh no, I never killed a snake.” “When you were about 14, you got mad at a snake and killed it.” And the guy says, “Oh, yeah, I wanted to go play with the other boys, and my dad wanted me to go sweep out the paddock. And I kicked over some boxes and there was a snake under one, and I got a hoe in my hand, so I just chopped his head off because I was mad.”

And Blue Horse said, “Well, the snake's spirit's mad at you now, and it's in your neck now, and it's hurting you like you hurt it. What I've done is I've asked the Great Spirit to intervene with the snake spirit. I can't ask the snake spirit because I don't know it, but the Great Spirit knows everybody. So I've asked him to say to the snake, you know, look, the man was only a boy, he didn't know what he was doing. He's sorry now, I'd like you to forgive him and leave him alone. And it takes four days for these things to reach the spirit world.”

So a few days later this guy says, “Hey, my neck's better.”

Do you know much about quantum physics?

I know some.

What a lot of hard-core, hard-line physicists are talking about is multiple universes, multiple dimensions of time ... all these guys are saying, look, it's likely there's multiple universes, and it's quite possible they all actually impact each other. It will be possible to go in time machines and go from one universe to another. I mean, these guys don't take prisoners when it comes to science; they have got bazillions of calculations behind them.

“When guys like this come up with the idea that there are actually infinite Blue Dragon [Coffeehouses] in infinite universes, isn't that weirder than a Navajo medicine man who can talk to the spirit of a dead snake?”

You know, when guys like this come up with the idea that there are actually infinite Blue Dragon [Coffeehouses] in infinite universes, and all our conversations are having infinitely different outcomes, isn't that weirder than a Navajo medicine man who can talk to the spirit of a dead snake?

When was the moment for you when you started believing?

I was very, very reluctant. With all my Western educational background, I do not believe in magic. I do not believe in mystic forces. And I still believe now that whatever the Navajos are doing is not magic. Somehow these guys may be tapping into some scientific effect which we cannot at the moment explain.

I mean, we don't have to go back very far--gravity. If that apple hadn't fallen on Isaac Newton's head, we'd probably still be wondering how we all sit still. I mean, there are things you can't see, but that doesn't mean they aren't there. Relativity is relativity. It's for real, no matter how unreal it may seem.

So I had a lot of issues with it. I really kept, for a long time, clinging to the idea that it was all mind tricks. I don't mean tricks in the way of fooling people, but kind of benign tricks, like every professional has their tricks. Doctors have their tricks.

But I think, actually, it was the moment he found the bead; I think that was the one when I thought, I don't know what the hell's going on around here, but this is not a trick.

The only way I can approach this is from a scientific manner. I believe that one day somebody—far cleverer than me, I have no doubt—will be able to figure out just what these guys are tapping into. They're definitely, I think, tapping into some rule of nature.

Electricity is still a very mysterious force, and it's not that long ago that, I forgot who ... one of the early scientists went to The Royal Society in London and had a glass jar with a sheepskin in it and a handle, and he'd put the lights out, whirl it round, and it was static electricity, but he'd say, look, gentlemen, I don't know what this is, but whatever it is, it's definitely there.

I'm in much the same position. I do not know what this is, but it's definitely there.

Who are the witch doctors going around cursing people, and why do they curse them? It's so preconceived.

This is where it gets a little bit scary, because a lot of these guys are, on the face of it, good medicine men. But they've sold out to the bad side. And people will offer them pretty large sums of money to go and curse somebody. And, in fact, some of the guys I've worked with said people have offered them thousands of dollars to do harm to people, and they won't do it.

Do you know what a skinwalker is?

I know that term is scary, but I'm not really familiar ...

A skinwalker is a kind of bad medicine man that actually ritually turns himself into an animal to get around. And I've had a couple of brushes with skinwalkers. You see, as a white man, I'm kind of protected against bad medicine. But as I've gotten further into it, I've kind of lost a lot of that protection, and there was a definite attempt to get me. Not that long ago, they sent a skinwalker after me. It was pretty scary.

What happened?

I upset a couple of medicine men. Now, how I upset them, I don't know. I didn't set out to upset them, but somehow I did. I was living in Farmington at the time. [In the middle of the night], this thing just started banging on my door. And this wasn't knocking (knocks on the table). It was Bam! Bam! Bam! And at first I thought, oh, this is my neighbor, knocking on his door. And then I thought, naw. I mean, he wasn't a noisy neighbor or anything like that.

So it would bang a few times and then it would stop. And it was regular. So I got out of bed, and I quietly walked down to the door, and I thought, the next time it knocks, I'm going to throw this door and I'm going to smack it in the face. So I stood there. And stood there. And stood there. And it didn't knock. So I went back to bed. Bang! Bang! Bang! And, you know, this was regular. There would be the same space of time, then Bang! Bang! Bang! And, again, this was not gentle. So I got out of bed, I crept to the door ... nothing. I went back to bed. Bang! Bang! Bang!

What really spooked me was the next morning when I went to the door, the screen door was closed and locked. So how'd he bang on the door through the screen? But that's what they do—I've heard it time and again.

And it came back the next night, but not so much. Because I wasn't scared of it. The Navajos tell me if I was scared of it, I just would have given it more power. And I regret now I didn't open the door and go jump out after it. They tell you that's what you shouldn't do. Although I have known a Navajo lady who's gone after a skinwalker.

What was that situation?

She said she ran out after it--a big owl that looked nothing like an owl; it was much bigger than it was supposed to be. And it flew off, very awkwardly. And as it flew away, she shouted after it, “No return message for you, then?”

When did you feel like this sort of alternate world started to open up to you?

[There was this one case some medicine men] were trying to explain to me in very scientific terms. And we're sitting in this truck stop café, and it was like the floor had been peeled back, and suddenly I was looking down into a completely different universe. All the stars were different ... everything. It was like the Navajo universe I was actually looking at, and it looked like nothing like I'd ever seen or was used to.

In that moment I suddenly became cognizant of the world these guys were living in. I mean, they speak English, they drive trucks, they watch TV, they use mobile phones, but actually, that's just the surface. Once you get under that, it's not just a different world, it's a different universe--and to me, utterly strange and unreal. And I was just kind of floating, waiting for these guys to guide me. And in that moment, I think, I realized that what I was getting into wasn't just something a bit different. It was a completely different universe.

“Somehow these guys may be tapping into some scientific effect which we cannot at the moment explain.”

I'm just trying to explain to you how it felt. It wasn't like the floor actually did come back. I just realized, I think, really for the first time, that this was not just something on the surface; this goes as deep as time. Because these guys' medicine goes back basically to the Ice Age. I mean, in England, you've got waves and waves of successive invaders and influences coming in. But these guys, their history goes back in a straight line at least to the last Ice Age.

What did your friends and family say when you did this?

Well, you've got to remember that I never set out to do this, so it's not like I woke up one day and said, hey, folks, I'm going off to the Navajos to become a medicine man.

I don't know—I've always been sort of a square peg. I wrote about 120 episodes of the worst TV soap in English television history, which was not my fault, that it was the worst, but it was. I've always been floating around doing other things.

But they all thought that probably I'd be better off doing something else. My mother absolutely hated it. You know, screaming at me, “Go get a job! Stop all this running around with all these Indians!” My kids are quite enthusiastic about it. But they're all grown up.

Before you ventured into this new life, did you hold many religious or spiritual beliefs? You refer to yourself as a man of science. Do you see conflict between those two things?

I don't see conflict at all. I can't claim to have been a deeply religious man or anything like that. But having said that, I do feel respectful toward it.

It seems like there are these two worlds that collide in certain ways. How do you reconcile those?

It's very difficult, actually. I mean, when I first started, it wasn't very difficult because I didn't really appreciate the sort of vast oceans of time and difference between the Indian world and our own. And I thought I could just go from one to the other very easily. But now it's getting a lot more difficult.

I've talked to a lady who works as a real estate agent. And she was telling me how difficult it is. You know, she gets up in the morning, she's an Indian. She does all the Indian things, gets her kids to school. Then she gets in her car, drives into Albuquerque, and she's a real estate agent. And then in the evening she goes back and reverses the whole process. And I'm beginning to understand how that splits her, because more and more I want to be there, but I've got term papers to write, got exams to take, got lectures to go to. But plenty of times, not only do I want to be there, I'm needed there. These guys need me, but I can't actually get out and go there.

I've had Indians say to me, “Sometime, you have to make a decision: Either you're going to be an Indian, or you're going to be a white man, and we decided to be Indians. And so we're not so well off here, but we're comfortable living here—we speak our own language, we have our ceremonies, and now I go to the white man's world to do the shopping at Wal-Mart. And that's fine; and then I come back.”

I'm beginning to get that pull. And it's an uncomfortable feeling. So I don't reconcile the two—it may not even be reconcilable. Cause the fact is, in a way, I'm in a worse position than most Indians—I can't decide whether I'm going to be an Indian or not. I'm never gonna be a Navajo.

So I don't have that choice. I can't decide to be an Indian and live on the reservation. All I can do is live in Albuquerque wishing I was.

What do you hope readers take away from your book?

I think if they read my book and say, that was interesting, I want to know more, that's about the sum of my ambitions. I don't think you can hope for anything but that.

I want to ask how this experience has changed you—but it seems like it's changed everything.

Yeah, totally. And it's still going on. I'm now at the stage where I know enough that I can actually start learning something. I used to run. And a lot of people don't understand that to train an athlete, basically, you have to train for a year until you can start to train seriously. It's kind of like that. It's taken me this long to accumulate enough knowledge to actually understand what I'm seeing. And even then, I'm pretty damn sure a lot of it's going right over my head. It's happening in front of me, but I don't get it.

What was the experience like of getting this book published?

I'm amazed this was really published at all. I mean, they're marketing it as a kind of travel book, because they don't know what to do with it. The publisher usually publishes books by professors.

They sent me this form to fill out, and it was for academics. It starts off with things like, "From which university did you get your PhD? If you have more than one, please list them." And I got thrown out of school when I was 16. So I'm just going through this form going, "not applicable ... N/A ... ." Then I get to, "What is the purpose of your book, and what social changes is it attempting to address?" No one's looking, so I wrote, "Make lots of money so I can spend it all on drugs." Then, "How many Nobel Prizes have you won?" "N/A."

I was going to change it, right? But I got distracted. And two days later I get this slightly pained phone call from the publishers in Boston: "Charles, I'm a little worried about one of your answers." "Oh, really? Which one?"

I got myself in trouble for being an anarchist at 16. Now I'm 57 and I'm still getting myself in trouble for the same reason.

Meeting the Medicine Men: An Englishman’s Travels Among the Navajo (Nicholas Brealey, $19.95) hits bookstores this month.

Public Comments (19)
  • WTF - whose medicine man and from what tribe?  [ Thu May 1 2008 1:59 PM ]

    The story talks about Navajo Medicine Men and you take a random photo of a guy at the Gathering of Nations as if he's one? Where's the integrity in images and how a group is defined, depicted in the minds of people who know little to nothing about such topics. Again, stereotypes abound in this story. Charles Langley needs to research his own "savage" and "noble" history to find a mystical place in this world and Christie Chisholm needs to do a little more research and the gods forbid ask a real Navajo Medicine Man what it means to be an "Indian." Such rubbish! JJ Otero (505) 249-1646

  • There were better stories @ Gathering of Nations Pow-wow  [ Thu May 1 2008 7:35 PM ]

    Honestly, how disappointing is it that the leas story in this publication and the only story that came out of GON pow-wow was about a wannabe medicine man. I can think of so many other more interesting topics that actually have to do with Indian people. The 25th Anniversary of GON, the economic impact of the pow-wow, did the economy affect turnout, or god forbid, the story of some Indian attendees.

    I'm curious if Chisholm (the author) just bumped into this guy or if he contacted her in order to get some press before his book is released.

    Chisholm if you want to write about medicine men, talk to a real one. Was there even a way to check Langley's "facts" or was the validity assumed based on the fact that he is an editor of an eminent London newspaper because honestly any fool could have made the claims that he did.

    It's just the same old story, a non-Indian telling the Indian's story (that is either falsified or not meant to be told) in order to gain attention and make a profit. The only difference is that Langley is obtaining the Anthropology degree after the experience, instead of before it, like his predecessors.

  • Slapped in the Face with your article  [ Fri May 2 2008 12:25 PM ]

    There are so many problems with this article and the man it features that I could probably write a dissertation about them (not to mention the images). But let's just start with how extremely offensive this is to read. There are thousands of Navajos that live in Albuquerque and you choose a white guy from England to tell Albuquerque, including those Navajo residents, about Navajo medicine men. The stereotypes and cultural appropriation for the benefit of Langely's book are so completely blatant, derogatory, and unethical. How ignorant can you be, Chisholm? Then, to have the gall to take a poll on the website about whether or not people believe in skinwalkers! How disrespectful. I guess you aimed for sensationalism because the "facts" that Langely purports to tell and that Chishom so readily shares are ludicrous. Langely needs to look deep within to fix his own screwed up identity and stop bothering Navajos. And Chisholm, go back to journalism school.

  • Shame  [ Fri May 2 2008 4:52 PM ]

    As a fan of the Alibi, I have to say I have strong disagreement with the publication of this article because it shows complete insensitivity and lack of understanding of traditional Native cultures. Native American beliefs are not something to be treated so disrespectfully. This type of journalism hurts Native American/non-Native relationships of all kinds because makes all Belaganas look bad and threatens trust between people that typically takes years to build. Does the Alibi have any traditional Native Americans on the staff? Do you have any on your advisory board? I would suggest that this be one of the first responses to this article. The Alibi (along with all the major media in Albuquerque) did not cover the Longest Walk 2 that crossed New Mexico last month. If you can't help spread important news for Native communities, you should at least learn some sensitivity to the nature of this subject. There were many elder Native Americans at the GON who have wonderful stories. What you have printed here is voyeurism. My final suggestion is to start reading the Navajo Times as a way to begin to understand how Navajos want to be presented in newspapers. You will learn something.

  • Shame  [ Fri May 2 2008 4:53 PM ]

    As a fan of the Alibi, I have to say I am in strong disagreement with the publication of this article because it shows complete insensitivity and lack of understanding of traditional Native cultures. Native American beliefs are not something to be treated so disrespectfully. This type of journalism hurts Native American/non-Native relationships of all kinds because makes all Belaganas look bad and threatens trust between people that typically takes years to build. Does the Alibi have any traditional Native Americans on the staff? Do you have any on your advisory board? I would suggest that this be one of the first responses to this article. The Alibi (along with all the major media in Albuquerque) did not cover the Longest Walk 2 that crossed New Mexico last month. If you can't help spread important news for Native communities, you should at least learn some sensitivity to the nature of this subject. There were many elder Native Americans at the GON who have wonderful stories. What you have printed here is voyeurism. My final suggestion is to start reading the Navajo Times as a way to begin to understand how Navajos want to be presented in newspapers. You will learn something.

  • Looks like  [ Fri May 2 2008 4:57 PM ]

    Everyone is vying for their comment to be posted in the next alibi

  • Author  [ Fri May 2 2008 7:23 PM ]

    Alibi published an interview with an author. If it pushed some buttons that's great, because it started a discussion and the end result will raise awareness. Pick up next week's issue to read the complaints and Langley's response.

  • hilarious  [ Sat May 3 2008 3:40 AM ]

    This is a hilarious article! The English man proclaims he has it "harder than the Indians", (this specific instance he means the Dine') in that he has to live in Albuquerque not live on the "rez", the Dine' rez I assume. News alert, this man is not Dine', he doesn't have to live in the trite phrased "two words", he is English! He is not Native, he is an anglo visitor to Navajoland! This man is in serious delusional identity crisis!

    The photos of this anglo "medicine man" are hilarious! Seriously are these photos supposed to be ironic or sincere? Is this the Santa Fe Reporter or what?

    Honestly, to answer the above comments, I think this article was printed because an English man who has an opinion about Native culture, in this case Dine' culture, is considered interesting (in my case, entertaining) and one shouldn't be surprised and/or angry that an actual Native wasn't consulted. Weekly entertainment newspapers are meant for just that, to entertain. This is faux journalism at its best.

    How boring would it be for a Native journalist to write about his own people to a bunch of anglos? They can't relate to any of that...

  • So many things wrong with Langley's story  [ Sat May 3 2008 10:28 AM ]

    For a moment, let's set aside the various culturally offensive aspects of Langley's interview (particularly the "myth of the noble savage" crap, and the perspective that a non-white culture isn't legitimized until a white guy experiences it). There are many events that Langley describes which your Navajo friends would point out as highly questionable or just plain wrong. You did ask your Navajo friends if Langley sounded legit, didn't you?

    In order of mention in Langey's interview:

    Although code talkers participate in many parades, especially on Veterans' Day, there are no parades specifically for code talkers. Certainly not in Window Rock.

    A Navajo man would not walk out of a parade crowd to tell a bilagaana (white guy) that he's never seen anyone like him. It's just not done.

    Medicine men don't announce that they're medicine men. They have a lot of enemies due to the nature of their work, e.g., transferring sickness from one person to another, breaking curses that someone paid another medicine man a lot of money to inflict, etc. And, when they're not dealing in the redistribution of suffering, they must maintain a graceful balance with a gazillion subtle forces in the physical and spiritual worlds. Self-promotion, or even self-identification, disrupts that.

    Medicine men and medicinal herbalists do, indeed, instruct in very conventional ways. It's not just "watch and try to absorb".

    But the teaching method is probably moot, since it's HIGHLY UNLIKELY a medicine man would share such deep tradition with any outsider, bilagaana or otherwise. They don't even share the knowledge among family or other Navajo unless they see the gift in another person, and that's not something that can be seen in one quick look.

    Medicine men also tend to work with a team, including, for example, an interpreter, an herbalist, an assistant who handles charms and such, etc. Langley speaks as if it's only ever him and Blue Horse.

    There are many, many forms of divination other than scrying a fire, and it's peculiar that Langley's Blue Horse seems to use that technique exclusively. Also, studying the smoke and ash are much more common that firegazing. And sand painting is perhaps the most common divination, yet Langley doesn't mention it at all.

    But then there's the skinwalker business. A medicine man would NEVER become a skinwalker himself. Instead, some poor malleable chump is chosen as victim of the skinwalker transformation. It's a kind of voluntary enslavement. You have to WANT to become a skinwalker and kill a close relative as your first step down that road. This is perhaps the darkest, most sinister aspect of a medicine man's work. And, the skinwalker doesn't become an animal. The skinwalker manifests the qualities of the animal that can accomplish the dark deeds at hand, sometimes as far as donning the hide of the animal and distorting his body to fit the hide.

    Finally, Langley says he can't decide to be an Indian and live on the rez. True, he'll always be bilagaana, but he can live on the rez if Navajo friends invite him to. It's peculiar that the people he spent so much time with, and shared such deep spiritual experiences with, wouldn't invite him. Perhaps there's more cachet to being the Albuquerque white guy who studied with medicine men. Or maybe his claims can't be as easily vetted in white society.

  • Stuff White People Like: Being an expert on YOUR culture  [ Sat May 3 2008 10:54 AM ]

    I really don't think I need to say any more....

    [link]

  • Concerned about the medicine men feature?  [ Mon May 5 2008 11:25 AM ]

    Call me today. I'm writing something up for the news section about the reaction.

    Marisa Demarco

    346-0660 x. 245

  • Question  [ Tue May 6 2008 8:39 AM ]

    I have to ask an obvious question that seems to have been left out of the article, did Langley apply for a permit from the Historic Preservation Department of the Navajo Nation to do this research?

  • A permit to study?  [ Tue May 6 2008 12:46 PM ]

    Please tell me you're joking.

  • Hear This;)   [ Tue May 6 2008 2:05 PM ]

    Charles Langley will be the guest on Wednesday's Native America Calling show.

    11-noon KUNM 89.9fm.

  • How Much Has Been Forgotten?  [ Tue May 6 2008 11:30 PM ]

    In terms of time, it really hasn't been that long. Maybe somewhere between 3 and 10 thousand years ago, what might be called a British version of the Navajo Medicine Man existed. Are those with such gifts that makes a Medicine Man born with these gifts? Are they trained into it ? I think it a matter of both.

    Langley doesn't seem to understand his gift. Yet he says other Medicine Men told him " but you are one of us, and we think you ought to come learn more about it." Langley is torn between two worlds, but the worlds are now continents apart. He wants to go live on a reservtion, but realizes he cannot. He might wish to consider finishing his training and then go home to the UK. That which has been lost can once again be rekindled in a land where the flames long ago died out.

  • This hasn't been mentioned yet...  [ Wed May 7 2008 11:23 PM ]

    I wish I would have thought of this is my original comment, but I have read all the other comments and I also listened to Langley's interview on Native American Calling and one question remains in my mind because of my Navajo background (but also my inability to speak/understand Navajo). I have attended several traditional Navajo ceremonies (some healing and some not) and in my experience the ceremonies in their entirety are conducted in Navajo (which I do not speak or understand). So, how is it that Langley understands what is going on? How can he train to be a medicine man if he doesn't speak the language? I know from my own experiences in these situations and from reading research about indigenous language revitalization that culture/traditional knowledge/ceremonies rely on one's ability to speak and understand the language. Right now indigenous language shift/loss is resulting in a decline of traditional knowledge and ceremonies. How is Langley able to transcend that?

  • Difrnt has a great point  [ Thu May 8 2008 10:38 AM ]

    there were/are European "medicine men": Merlin the Wizard, Nostradamus, John Lennon, Cat Stevens, Ozzy Osbourne and on and on. I'm serious...I can guarantee that everyone here has heard something and GAINED insight by one of these men's teachings/creations. THAT is what a medicine man should do and should be. They heal, they teach, they have an undeniable gift from a higher power and as flawed as all humans are, they can use it to nurture life and create harmony or they can attempt to snuff you out.

    I'm gonna sort this shit out for you:

    look guys, if you try really hard, you can fill in the blanks and see that the guy in the picture is either a "Seminole" or a big Florida State fan from what it looks like in gang-style tattoo on his belly. (Most Navajo medicine men I know wear jeans and t-shirts, and unless they were in the Navy or a juvenile delinquent--have no tattoos)...so score one for the stereotype argument. BUT, how many people go to the Gathering of Nations (and other PowWows) and see and hear Navajos or Pueblo People singing PowWow songs in style and content from OTHER TRIBES? Deduct one point for perpetuating our own stereotype...PowWows are not even a Navajo tradition, but the performers all flock there for cash and prizes for dancing and drumming.

    Next, cut Ms. Chisolm some slack...she was doing a piece on a BOOK that LANGLEY wrote, not presenting her own research. She didn't have to consult any Indians to publish an INTERVIEW.

    What was she going to do? Stop some random Indian on the street to get a permission slip? Or Call the Navajo Tribal Office and ask to speak with a consultant? Those guys in Window Rock are so damn corrupt they probably have a fee built into that type of inquiry.....oh wait, didn't someone say there is a required PERMIT to do research?!? Those dirtbags want to build a multimillion dollar Council chamber while thousands of Navajos are hopelessly unemployed and unemployable, addicted to meth, alchoholics, and living in shitty conditions with no access to water and no electricity. Real Indians don't need running water and electricity you say? Then you are a fool...look at the Infant Mortality rate on the rez. The adults might not need these things, but fragile babies do.

    I'm going to say this once and for all, and it is a viewpoint that I have held for a long time: We need to QUIT concerning ourselves with horseshit ie-being "stereotyped" by white people. What is a typical Indian anyway? I couldn't tell you, but look at that fungus Robert Miribal with his bone necklace and fancy hair winning a Grammy and bringing his fantasty wild west indian show to the masses...THAT is who you should be point fingers at. Dude looks like a fool.

    We need to QUIT whining aimlessly about every single issue that comes up and DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT...my ANGLO Father made alot of sense when he said to me: "You can want in one hand and shit into the other...see shich one fills up first". Wanting things to be different will never be enough.

    This brings me to a question:

    How many Indians that are pissed off about the article have taken the time to volunteer your own quality time and resources to NATIVE YOUTH? NATIVE ELDERS? YOUR OWN PEOPLE? YOUR OWN FAMILY? YOURSELF? WITHOUT TAKING ANY CREDIT OR EXPECTING ANYTHING IN RETURN? (There are those that do, and I respect that...I'm not talking about you.)

    Who has decided to make your contribution by pointing fingers and feeling good about yourselves? I am a member of a Native News Yahoo Group and EVERYDAY get e-mail alerts and NATIONWIDE I see nothing but a long list of complaints and NO RESULTS or FOLLOWTHRU!!! It seems that Indians are quite reactive anymore--sit back and WAIT for someone else to do the work for them or wait for someone to say ANYTHING at all about Native people and then react by dissecting the words and cursing the people behind them--WITHOUT SEEING THE BIGGER PICTURE--That BOOK is INTEDED to fulfill a curiousity of the author firstly and to make the author some money secondly. BUT it is also intended, without malice, to educate and raise awareness about the Navajo Culture...If you're going to feel betrayed by knowing that a white man was researching for a book and yearning for understanding of our sacred culture, be pissed at THE NAVAJOS THAT LET THEM DO THIS RESEARCH! It's not Langley's fault and not the Alibi's fault and CERTAINLY NOT Christy Chisholm's fault for giving him some press and fulfilling an assignment.

    Be proactive and get out and do something for your people if you are so damn concerned about this issue. If you're unsure where to start...start with yourself, then your family, then move on from there.

    Rod Lacy

  • good point  [ Thu May 8 2008 10:45 AM ]

    Difrnt has a great point...

    there were/are European "medicine men": Merlin the Wizard, Nostradamus, John Lennon, Cat Stevens, Ozzy Osbourne and on and on. I'm serious...I can guarantee that everyone here has heard something and GAINED insight by one of these men's teachings/creations. THAT is what a medicine man should do and should be. They heal, they teach, they have an undeniable gift from a higher power and as flawed as all humans are, they can use it to nurture life and create harmony or they can attempt to snuff you out.

    I'm gonna sort this shit out for you:

    look guys, if you try really hard, you can fill in the blanks and see that the guy in the picture is either a "Seminole" or a big Florida State fan from what it looks like in gang-style tattoo on his belly. (Most Navajo medicine men I know wear jeans and t-shirts, and unless they were in the Navy or a juvenile delinquent--have no tattoos)...so score one for the stereotype argument. BUT, how many people go to the Gathering of Nations (and other PowWows) and see and hear Navajos or Pueblo People singing PowWow songs in style and content from OTHER TRIBES? Deduct one point for perpetuating our own stereotype...PowWows are not even a Navajo tradition, but the performers all flock there for cash and prizes for dancing and drumming.

    Next, cut Ms. Chisolm some slack...she was doing a piece on a BOOK that LANGLEY wrote, not presenting her own research. She didn't have to consult any Indians to publish an INTERVIEW.

    What was she going to do? Stop some random Indian on the street to get a permission slip? Or Call the Navajo Tribal Office and ask to speak with a consultant? Those guys in Window Rock are so damn corrupt they probably have a fee built into that type of inquiry.....oh wait, didn't someone say there is a required PERMIT to do research?!? Those dirtbags want to build a multimillion dollar Council chamber while thousands of Navajos are hopelessly unemployed and unemployable, addicted to meth, alchoholics, and living in shitty conditions with no access to water and no electricity. Real Indians don't need running water and electricity you say? Then you are a fool...look at the Infant Mortality rate on the rez. The adults might not need these things, but fragile babies do.

    I'm going to say this once and for all, and it is a viewpoint that I have held for a long time: We need to QUIT concerning ourselves with horseshit ie-being "stereotyped" by white people. What is a typical Indian anyway? I couldn't tell you, but look at that fungus Robert Miribal with his bone necklace and fancy hair winning a Grammy and bringing his fantasty wild west indian show to the masses...THAT is who you should be point fingers at. Dude looks like a fool.

    We need to QUIT whining aimlessly about every single issue that comes up and DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT...my ANGLO Father made alot of sense when he said to me: "You can want in one hand and shit into the other...see shich one fills up first". Wanting things to be different will never be enough.

    This brings me to a question:

    How many Indians that are pissed off about the article have taken the time to volunteer your own quality time and resources to NATIVE YOUTH? NATIVE ELDERS? YOUR OWN PEOPLE? YOUR OWN FAMILY? YOURSELF? WITHOUT TAKING ANY CREDIT OR EXPECTING ANYTHING IN RETURN? (There are those that do, and I respect that...I'm not talking about you.)

    Who has decided to make your contribution by pointing fingers and feeling good about yourselves? I am a member of a Native News Yahoo Group and EVERYDAY get e-mail alerts and NATIONWIDE I see nothing but a long list of complaints and NO RESULTS or FOLLOWTHRU!!! It seems that Indians are quite reactive anymore--sit back and WAIT for someone else to do the work for them or wait for someone to say ANYTHING at all about Native people and then react by dissecting the words and cursing the people behind them--WITHOUT SEEING THE BIGGER PICTURE--That BOOK is INTEDED to fulfill a curiousity of the author firstly and to make the author some money secondly. BUT it is also intended, without malice, to educate and raise awareness about the Navajo Culture...If you're going to feel betrayed by knowing that a white man was researching for a book and yearning for understanding of our sacred culture, be pissed at THE NAVAJOS THAT LET THEM DO THIS RESEARCH! It's not Langley's fault and not the Alibi's fault and CERTAINLY NOT Christy Chisholm's fault for giving him some press and fulfilling an assignment.

    Be proactive and get out and do something for your people if you are so damn concerned about this issue. If you're unsure where to start...start with yourself, then your family, then move on from there.

    **Oh, and if you don't want to share your culture with them, then be fair and BURN your ipod and CDs from any of the guys I mentioned (and more) at the beginning...seriously.

    Rod Lacy

  • Still disgusted  [ Thu May 8 2008 11:09 AM ]

    After reading his responses and listening to his interview and comments on Native American Calling, I still have the same opinion that I had of Langley when I first read “Good Medicine” in the Alibi. Langley’s responses in the Opinion section of the Alibi and in Native American Calling reinforce his lack of cultural sensitivity. I can’t help but feel that he is just a failed writer trying to make a quick buck.

    I’m still convinced he got most of his material from the likes of Tony Hillerman novels. A few listeners pointed out to him yesterday that the ceremonies he described in his book are those of the Native American Church, not traditional Navajo ceremonies. Even the cover of his book shows a picture of a tipi. Since when do traditional Navajos live in tipis? Langley claims that he participated in a variety of healing ceremonies, Navajo and NAC, but where does he make this distinction clear? Does that mean that to him, there’s no difference between a traditional Navajo ceremony or any other Native healing ceremonies? Also, the comment by wazure in the "Good Medicine" article makes a good point in asking “how is it that Langley understands what is going on? How can he train to be a medicine man if he doesn't speak the language?”

    Langley also claims that “It just happened” when asked about his reason for following around Navajo medicine men. Oh, please. It’s not like anyone tied him up, strapped him to the seat of their pickup trucks, and forced him to tag along. If he really was allowed to tag-along, he had a choice to do so.

    Finally, Langley claims that he’s not trying to be a medicine man and at most, he was just the driver and bell boy for the real medicine men. If he isn’t trying to be a medicine man, then what the heck is up with those pictures in the article of him dressed in Native gear, particularly the photo with the subscript “Razzle Dazzle” taken at the Gathering of Nations powwow. If he’s not trying to be Native there, then what is he doing, showing his support as a fan for the Washington Redskins?

    I know lots of non-Natives have healing powers as Langley claims he does, but this guy needs to find a place of his own even though he says the European history of has been “wiped out by industrialization.” Langley says he was prompted to write the book through encouragement by the medicine men who feel that they have been improperly portrayed in the past. Well, sorry to say, Langley’s book doesn’t help one bit and the medicine men and Navajo people are still stereotyped. He says he picked and chose his experiences to write about because he wrote it for “his own people” to become aware of Navajo culture. Well Mr. Langley, picking and choosing only the “mystical” and “superstitious” aspects of Navajo people, particularly the stories and ideas of witchcraft in the fashion of a fiction novel is not the way we as Navajo people want our culture to be portrayed or learned about. I’d encourage you to take some Native American Studies classes while you’re at UNM. If you really want to help others learn about Native peoples, then start by learning yourself. Learn how to take a more appropriate approach of interacting with, gaining knowledge of, and writing about Native peoples. On the off-chance that everything he said happened is true, then he needs to learn how to treat his knowledge with the respect it deserves and when he shares it, to present it in a way that does not harm the cultures he is talking about.

 
Join our mailing list for exclusive info, the week's events and free stuff!
 

  • Select sidebar boxes to add below. You can also click and drag to rearrange the boxes; minimize, maximize and close using the little icons on each box. To re-add a box you closed, return to this menu.
  • Because you are not logged in, any changes you make to these boxes will vanish as soon as you click to another page. If you log in, the boxes will stick.
  • alibi.com
  • Latest Posts
  • Most Active Stories
  • Latest User Posts
  • Highest-Rated Posts
  • Most Active Users
  • Web Exclusives
  • Latest User Blogs
  • Latest Chowtown Reviews
  • Recent Rocksquawk Discussions
  • Recent Classifieds
  • This Week's Alibi Picks
  • Albuquerque
  • Duke City Fix
  • Albuquerque Beer Scene
  • What's Wrong With This Picture?
  • Reddit Albuquerque
  • ABQ Journal Metro
  • ABQrising
  • ABQ Journal Latest News
  • Del.icio.us Albuquerque
  • NM and the West
  • New Mexico FBIHOP
  • Democracy for New Mexico
  • Only in New Mexico
  • Mario Burgos
  • Democracy for New Mexico
  • High Country News
  • El Grito
  • NM Politics with Joe Monahan
  • Stephen W. Terrell's Web Log
  • The Net Is Vast and Infinite
  • Slashdot
  • Freedom to Tinker
  • Is there a feed that should be on this list? Tell us about it.
    NM Sol Splash Reggae Fest
    NM Sol Splash Reggae Fest6.29.2013