Alibi Bucks
 Sep 13 - 19, 2012 

Bear With Me

Unemployment Blues


The late Bill Call, a colorful Texas journalist-friend of mine, once said emergency management agencies were a solution looking for a problem. The words “solution” followed by “problem” bear special meaning to me, after months of form letters and sullen, vaguely threatening phone calls I have endured from the ironically titled Department of Workforce Solutions.

Some relevant background: I have been convicted (a very serious word indeed) of unemployment fraud, for underreporting part-time employment. The underreported amount was ... one dollar. I have been appealing, unsuccessfully, for six months.

I swear that I am not a crook, just incredibly incompetent with paperwork involving numbers.

Like millions of other Americans, I lost my job. Not because the Republican Party destroyed the economy. No, I was actually fired for insubordination. I like to think that I was disobeying an unjust boss, which makes me a patriot. My mom prefers to say I was fired for writing, which makes me an artist.

The benevolent state of New Mexico agreed with my mom, and awarded me unemployment. It turns out you need a reason to fire someone. Things were looking back up. Maybe I wouldn't starve after all.

I am pretty sure I would have gotten a warmer reception if I were to walk naked and flailing into a 7-11 and ask to use the phone.

About two months later, I took a part-time job. I like to work. Truth be told, I would have made $10 more per week suckling the government teat and writing bad poetry.

But the gig was a welcome relief. Dealing with the folks at Workforce Solutions was proving to be quite a drag. I am pretty sure I would have gotten a warmer reception if I were to walk naked and flailing into a 7-11 and ask to use the phone.

There was a problem: I made $250 a week. Gross. About $220 a week after taxes. I claimed what I now know is called “net pay,” the amount of money you actually have to spend on food and used paperbacks.

I was supposed to claim $250, which, it turns out, is $1 above the weekly limit for income.

I claimed the wrong number. Anyone who knew me when I was crying over first-grade math or crying over basic algebra would not doubt my sincerity when I say that math is not my forte.

Eventually I left the part-time job to embark on a series of personal tragedies too hilarious to list here. Let's just say that it was like Knocked Up re-imagined by an Italian neorealist director.

What I've learned: I would sooner sleep under a bridge than go on unemployment again.

Because I left my part-time gig to seek full-time work in another city, I no longer qualified for unemployment. After 18 more months of watching 18 hours of MSNBC a day with my stepfather, I landed a job. Happy ending, right?

Well, guess what? Soon the mail started coming. Form letters from Workforce Solutions. Two words caught my eye: “fraud” and “investigation.”

Once I recovered from feeling pretty deeply offended, I wrote a letter proclaiming my innocence. There had to be a mistake. I am compulsively honest. It's like a goddamn disease.

No luck. Guilty. Pay us $2,257. You have 30 days—or we suppose you can appeal.

I appealed. I got a chance to speak with a real live judge. I told my side: the lost job, moving home, making a mistake because I was under a lot of pressure, finding a new job, the fear that getting my check docked would wipe me out and make me lose said new job. I told the judge that I was a reporter, that my word was all I had, that being called a liar and a cheat was, well, horrifying to me.

Maybe I was a little frantic. But I was polite and respectful.

I thought I had been given an advantage by the investigator from Workforce Solutions—the “prosecution,” if you will. She was rude, insolent even. At one point she said huffily, as if I were not present and she were clairvoyant, “He knows what he did.” The judge had to have heard this and would save me.

I was denied. Then my appeal of that denial was denied. So I gave up. I submitted. Like Chief Joseph finally concluded, I would fight no more forever. I called the number to arrange payment.

No one replied. For two weeks.

I called again. This time, a gentleman manning the phones said I had to pay $249 a month or Workforce Solutions would take me to court. I said I can't pay that much. He said I had to pay $249 a month or they would take me to court. I said fine, and that I hoped he and his coworkers were having a chuckle. He said this was no laughing matter, Sir, and assured me that no one was having a chuckle. Not a big sarcasm guy, but he has a bright future in collections.

What I've learned: I would sooner sleep under a bridge than go on unemployment again.

I think of all those people who have lost their jobs in this economy—not because they have a problem with authority figures—and who may also have other folks dependent upon them for the basics. Are they also treated like shiftless scumbags if they take a wrong turn in the complex maze of Workforce Solutions?

John Bear is a backpack journalist, which means he writes, takes photos and edits. He blogs at He lives with his cat, Scoop.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.

NEWSLETTERS Great Alibi stories, events and deals delivered to your inbox each week. No fooling!
View desktop version