alibi online
Free Will AstrologyAlibi's Personals
 
 V.21 No.17 | April 26 - May 2, 2012 
Play Youtube Video

Idiot Box

Diversi-TV

1-2-3-4 ... What are we fighting for?

A mere two weeks after its debut, HBO’s ballsy, awkward and uncomfortably honest comedy “Girls” has become a surprising lightning rod for controversy. Depending upon which website you visit, the show is either a refreshingly feminist take on coming-of-age sitcoms or a distressingly antifeminist take on the same. Also, it’s the product of nepotism. (Dunham is the daughter of art photographer Laurie Simmonsyou know, Laurie Simmons. Plus, one of the other girls on the show is the daughter of the ex-drummer from Bad Companyimagine how many doors that opens in Hollywood.) To top it all off, the show is being castigated becausefor all its Gen Y realismit’s about four white girls and not some idealized, racially diversified group of New Yorkers.

On TheHairpin.com, critic Jenna Wortham (a self-described “white girl and not a white girl ... which in mixed people speak means biracial”) kinda-sorta liked the show, but concluded, “I just wish I saw a little more of myself on screen.” Shortly thereafter, “Girls” writer Lesley Arfin responded by Tweeting, “What really bothered me about Precious was that there was no representation of ME.” Now, this could be the sort of cultural catfight that leads to a lot of hurt feelings and the occasional short-lived reexamination of our pop cultural standards. But before we ask which side is right (both, I’m inclined to answer), we might want to break this down a bit.

Basically, people are arguing over how much a cable TV sitcom is doing to advance the cause of gender and racial equality. Isn’t that a lot to ask of the same medium that gave us “ALF”? It’s not that “art” has no influence over our culture, it’s just that ... well, shouldn’t we be posing these sorts of questions to people who have a little more direct control over life in these United States? It could be pointed out, for example, that a very viable candidate for president (Mitt Romney) doesn’t even support the idea of equal pay for equal work (the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act). Maybe we should be bugging the government about diversity and equality and not 25-year-old screenwriter Lena Dunham.

Of course, if a controversy-baiting television show was the only one generating controversy, this might not be such a big issue. On the same week that Dunham’s show got dragged into the mud for its lack of diversity, somebody came up with the bright idea of suing “The Bachelor” for racial discrimination. Two African-American men, Nathaniel Claybrooks and Christopher Johnson, filed a federal lawsuit against ABC and its inexplicably popular dating shows “The Bachelor” and “The Bachelorette.” The lawsuit claims that, for 10 years, the shows have engaged in patterns of racial discrimination, blocking certain ethnic groups from taking either of the two titular positions. True enough, Jake Pavelka is a major cracker. But what are we actually fighting for here? The opportunity to be on a reprehensible fake dating show? Before even confronting concerns about America’s “readiness” for interracial dating or the troubling ratings dip such an enterprise might experience, I have to ask: Would landing the lead role on some stereotypical CBS sitcom or asking strangers to marry you on an awful reality show be a step forward or a big step backward?

 

Today's Events

Black Friday (1940) at KiMo Theatre

Classic horror film starring Boris Karloff and Bela Lugosi. Part of the Fright Nights series.

Cine de la Epoca de Oro: Pueblerina at South Broadway Cultural Center

Tomorrow's Events

Dance With Me at National Hispanic Cultural Center

More Recommented Events ››
Join our mailing list for exclusive info, the week's events and free stuff!
 

  • Select sidebar boxes to add below. You can also click and drag to rearrange the boxes; close using the little X icons on each box. To re-add a box you closed, return to this menu.
  • Because you are not logged in, any changes you make to these boxes will vanish as soon as you click to another page. If you log in, the boxes will stick.
  • alibi.com
  • Latest Posts
  • Web Exclusives
  • Recent Rocksquawk Discussions
  • Recent Classifieds
  • Latest User Posts
  • Most Active Users
  • Most Active Stories
  • Calendar Comments
  • Upcoming Alibi Picks
  • Albuquerque
  • Duke City Fix
  • Albuquerque Beer Scene
  • What's Wrong With This Picture?
  • Reddit Albuquerque
  • ABQ Journal Metro
  • ABQrising
  • ABQ Journal Latest News
  • Del.icio.us Albuquerque
  • NM and the West
  • New Mexico FBIHOP
  • Democracy for New Mexico
  • Only in New Mexico
  • Mario Burgos
  • Democracy for New Mexico
  • High Country News
  • El Grito
  • NM Politics with Joe Monahan
  • Stephen W. Terrell's Web Log
  • The Net Is Vast and Infinite
  • Slashdot
  • Freedom to Tinker
  • Is there a feed that should be on this list? Tell us about it.
    High Mountain Hideout
    High Mountain Hideout8.29.2014